Schachter Energy Report

Eye on Energy: December 31
Schachter's Eye on Energy

Next Decline In Crude Prices Below US$68/b Should Trigger A New Long Term BUY Signal For The Sector.

happy new year from the ser team!

 

The next decline in crude oil prices (downside target range of US$66-68/b) should trigger a new long-term buy signal for the sector. Normally just one of the three signals we watch is sufficient for us to send out BUY recommendations. This is what happened in September (September 10th) when WTI fell to US$66/b and we sent out an Action BUY signal and added five new energy ideas to our BUY list. We are watching our three indicators (WTI price, S&P/TSX Energy Index level and the S&P Energy Bullish Percent Index) and we may see more than one of these signals triggered in the coming weeks. When this happens we will send an email to SER subscribers with new BUY ideas and note those stocks that are at bargain levels for subscribers to consider. This next BUY window may see more than one signal being triggered at the same time which historically has been a high reward situation. The last time this occurred was in March 2020, a very rewarding BUY window for investors. Keep an eye out for an SER Action Alert in the coming weeks. We see January 2025 as likely a weak general stock market period. 

Global Economic, Political & Military Update

The Biden administration is leaving in three weeks and they continue to spend all the funds authorized by Congress and that the President can spend under Presidential authority. The result may be that the incoming administration comes in with a run rate of a US$3T+ deficit and all Biden’s favourite programs (climate, more government hiring etc.) seeing all getting more funds to spend making it harder for the new administration to see the policies that they were elected on being implemented. If the goal of the Biden administration was to leave the new administration with geopolitical, financial and economic challenges they have succeeded. It is unlikely that the people’s business will be done in the next few months as political drama unfortunately wins the stage. This transition seems to be one of the worst ever as White House staffers do everything they can to make the start of Trump’s Presidency difficult. 

President Trump will likely focus initially on the border crisis and boosting US energy production, while his DOGE team gets a handle on government waste. This while the President’s key cabinet and other lieutenants go through the Senate confirmation process. It is unlikely that any major action will occur in the Congress as the first battle is electing the Republican Speaker of the House which may not be an easy vote. With a slim majority even a few votes against current Speaker Johnston could derail Trump’s goal of massive changes in his first 100 days. One victory for incoming President Trump was getting a court halting Biden’s sale of 11,000 bollards used to build the border wall. If not achieved this would have delayed work on adding to the border wall and border security. 

Treasury Secretary Yellin has added to the incoming administration woes by using up the remaining Treasury cash on Biden programs so that the debt level hits the limit in January. This would force either a government shutdown or a deal that gives Democrats lots of their policy interests (i.e. pork spending) that differ from Trump’s spending priorities. A period of political strife is not what the markets are expecting in January. One more problem for the incoming administration is that financing of the debt maturities (nearly US$10T in 2025) will occur at rates over 4.5% compared to their  funding rate of 2.5%, on an average basis. Add in a large 2025 deficit of US$3T and that is why we are seeing long term US interest rates rising while short term interest rates are declining.  

On the geopolitical front a deal to end the hostage crisis in Gaza and the war in Ukraine may take a back burner as Trump’s team tries to take over the levers of power in Washington. The anti-Trump bureaucracy may take time to weed out or be forced to implement the new adminstration’s policies that they were elected on. Expect the Democratic Congress to be difficult to work with as they are abhorrent to shrinking the size of government or any of its programs or perks. 

In our upcoming first SER issue of 2025 to come out on January 16th we plan to cover the following topics which may impact the investment markets. If these are of interest to you, become a subscriber.

  • Inflation may be re-igniting. Food costs led by eggs due to the flu disease as well as ranchers culling herds due to poor economics will lead to much higher food inflation in coming months.
  • The US will likely hit its debt ceiling in January forcing either a government shut down or an agreement with Congress that delays Trump’s extension of the tax cuts and slows his shrinking of the bloated government employment levels or requiring all government workers to go back to the office and ending Covid’s remote working. 
  • Job openings are shrinking so this may be a predecessor of recession. We saw this in 2001 and 2019 and recessions occurred thereafter. 
  • US long term Treasury yields have lifted nearly 50 BP despite the Fed lowering its short term Fed Funds rate. The 10-year yield has lifted to 4.58% (December 31) from 4.13% in early December. What is happening? Has crowding out started?
  • Both the Bank of England and the US Fed are so worried about another round of bank failures that they are not releasing their moves until after the failed bank has been resolved. They did not do this in 2008 – 2009.
  • Will Trump’s Tariffs hurt or help the US economy and what impact will that have on the rest of the world.
  • The US Dollar has been very strong since late September rising from 99.86 to 108.29 last week. What is in store for the US Dollar in 2025?
  • Many countries are facing budgetary crises and are seeing rates rise sharply. Why we may see a Sovereign debt crisis in 2025 which will result in a rush to hide in a safe place – that being the US.
  • President Elect Trump is calling for ‘drill baby drill’ but also for gasoline prices at the pump to be cut in half. Why this is hyperbole and not realistic. 
  • Why we see commodities being a big winning part of the markets in 2025 and energy (especially crude oil) will be the largest contributor to this upside. We were cautious in 2024 and now we are again against the consensus. 

Geopolitical Military Issues:

Ukraine/Russia – Russia Moves Aggressively before January 20th

Russia is speeding its attacks against Ukraine’s forces that invaded Kursk. Putin wants to expel the invaders before January 20th. It would give him more bargaining power when President Trump pushes for a diplomatic solution. Ukraine is sending in more forces to make this difficult but from the battlefield they have lost over half of their initial invasion land capture. Large concentrations of Russian and North Korean forces are driving the land recovery operation. From reports over 1,100 North Korean troops have been killed so far in this offensive. North Korea is sending Russia more military manpower, ammunition, rocket launchers, suicide drones and self-propelled artillery to aid Russia as their relationship expands. North Korea is gaining modern warfare experience, food aid, crude oil, advanced space technologies and money from Russia. North Korea’s military industrial complex is running flat out to supply Russia with needed munitions and equipment. 

Russia has escalated its attacks on Ukraine’s energy infrastructure, major cities (Kiev today) and military bases as it works to gain leverage when diplomatic efforts commence in late January. Over 50% of Ukrainians were without power after these attacks. Russia has recently severed a key undersea power cable between Finland and Estonia as it goes after those countries supporting Ukraine but in an indirect manner so as not to start WWIII.

Israel versus Iran Proxies

Israel has ramped up attacks against Houthis that fired missiles into southern Israel. They hit two power stations and the air bases for drones at the main airport. Iran still seems to find supporters willing to attack Israel on their behalf. At some point Israel may go after the IRGC military bases and assets in Iran to warn them to stop aiding their nearly wiped out proxies. Somehow Hamas is still able to fire missiles into Israel despite the decapitation of their leadership and destruction of their brigades. 

Regarding energy, 

Our WTI price target of US$66-69/b was reached in September and is likely to do so again in the coming weeks. Today WTI is at US$71.80/b. We expect a period of backing and filling for WTI crude in the coming weeks and another test of the lows (US$66-68/b). When this occurs we should see another BUY signal triggered. We plan to add additional BUY ideas at that time. Subscribers please watch your emails on weak market days as this is when such an Action Alert would be issued. 

If you want to see what our subscribers are looking at, sign up now for access to the Schachter Energy Research reports.

EIA Weekly Oil Data:

The EIA data for last week was a bullish report. US Commercial Crude Inventories shrunk 4.2 Mb offset by the SPR growing by a modest 300 Kb. Total Stocks (Including the SPR) fell 12.4 Mb. Domestic production remained at 13.6 Mb/d nearly 300 Kb/d above 2023 levels. US Exports fell 1.17 Mb/d to 3.72 Mb/d. Total Product Supplied increased 1.01 Mb/d to 21.8 Mb/d as Other Oil demand rose 739 Kb/d and Propane demand rose 453 Kb/d.  Motor Gasoline demand grew by 80 Kb/d last week to 9.0 Mb/d, while Jet Fuel demand rose 105 Kb/d to 1.82 Mb/d. Distillate Fuel Oil demand fell 245 Kb/d to 4.25 Mb/d. Refinery Utilization came in at 92.5% up 0.7% from last week and just below the 2023 level of 93.3%. Cushing Storage fell 300 Kb to 22.7 Mb and was significantly below 34.0 Mb held in 2023. 

Total US Demand is year-to-date at 20.3 Mb/d up 0.3% from 20.2 Mb/d in 2023. Motor Gasoline Demand is at 8.86 Mb/d up 0.3% from 8.83 Mb/d in 2023. This positive comparison is why we see 2025 US consumption rising. 

EIA Weekly Natural Gas Data

The natural gas report out last week showed the third withdrawal of the season so far. Storage fell 93 Bcf to 3.53 Tcf with the largest decline in the Midwest with a 47 Bcf withdrawal. This compares to a decrease of 87 Bcf last year and the 5-year average withdrawal rate of 110 Bcf. With winter here, withdrawal rates should pick up significantly. We expect to see many weeks of withdrawals over 200 Bcf per week this winter season. US Storage is now 0.4% above last year’s level of 3.52 Tcf and is 4.9% above the five year average of 3.36 Tcf. The percent differences are clearly shrinking and when they go negative on a comparison basis natural gas prices should rise materially. NYMEX is today priced at US$3.61/mcf. Colder weather (a significant blizzard) is expected next week across the east coast of the US which should lift natural gas prices over US$4.00/mcf. Spikes over US$5/mcf should be seen this winter during very cold days when electricity systems are maxed out. 

We recommend buying the very depressed natural gas stocks during periods of market weakness. Natural gas stocks are very cheap now. We see much much higher gas prices in 2H/25 as quite a number of new LNG plants come onstream over the next 12 months; one in Canada and two more in the US. In Canada the first train of LNG Canada comes on during Q2/25 and in the US Corpus Christi Stage 3 begins production of LNG (1.5 Bcf/d). In 2025, Golden Pass LNG is bringing on the first two trains of this new three train export facility. The US saw a ramp-up in feedgas deliveries to an all time high of more than 15.3 Bcf/d last week as the new Plaquemines LNG plant started up and shipped its first cargo to Germany. 

DUE TO POPULAR DEMAND WE HAVE EXTENDED THE HOLIDAY DEAL UNTIL JANUARY 17TH FOR NEW SUBSCRIBERS!

holiday special

We are offering a special deal for new subscribers for the holiday season. Get $100 off for your first annual term with code HOLA24 or $50 off your first quarter term with code HOLQ24. Now is a great time to subscribe as there are many bargains to invest in. To subscribe click on the link below and make sure to type in the coupon code. https://schachterenergyreport.ca/subscriptions/

Baker Hughes Rig Data

In the data for the week ending December 27th, the US rig count saw rigs hold at 589 rigs. Rig activity is now 5.3% below the level of 622 rigs working last year. Of the total US rigs working last week, 483 were drilling for oil and this is 3.4% below last year’s level of 500 rigs working. The natural gas rig count is down 15.0% from last year’s 120 rigs, now at 102 rigs. This decline in drilling and production should continue for a few more months as the industry waits to see Trump’s industry support and the industry waits to see natural gas inventories fall below the five-year average. Once this occurs we should see NYMEX prices recover. Weak WTI prices at this time should slow energy companies drilling plans for early 2025.

In Canada, there was a 71 rig decrease to 95 rigs due to the winter year end slowdown for holidays for staff. This however is still 9 rigs above last year’s 86 rigs, or up by 10.4%. The industry needs north of $2.50/mcf to see the economics attractive to drill dry gas wells. As we get closer to LNG Canada ramping up in 1H/25 and natural gas fills the Coastal GasLink pipeline, prices should lift. AECO prices are at uneconomic prices around $1.80/mcf. The gas drilling rig count is down five rigs this week to 51 rigs and this is 13.6% below last year’s level of 59 rigs. Crude rigs fell 66 on the week to 44 rigs but are up 63% from last year’s level of 27 rigs. Starting week two of January we should see these numbers rise quickly as the industry returns to work with funds from 2025 budgets. 

Energy Stock Market

The S&P/TSX Energy Index today is at 266, up six points since our report last week. Our downside target for this indicator remains below 240 (range 230-240 – that is not far away) and we see this happening over the coming weeks. We like to BUY when stocks are cheap and being ignored. Bargains are clearly being seen now in our focus for new recommendations. WTI has traded between US$65.27/b and US$78.46/b over the past few months. The higher end when there are war actions in the Middle East with Iran involved and the lower end when weak crude demand data is released.

Investors should decide what you want your energy weighting to be for this long energy super cycle. Our BUY List includes ideas from the Pipeline/Infrastructure/Royalty area, Canadian oil and natural gas ideas, energy service ideas and companies working internationally. Our list includes large Conservative ideas and small to large caps in our Growth and Entrepreneurial categories. Add to your current ideas or add new ideas. We expect that WTI should lift above US$90/b in 2H/25 and demand should exceed supplies at that time. We see WTI prices above US$100/b consistently during 2026. 

We expect we are close to another low risk entry point like we saw on September 10th when we sent out an Action Alert BUY with five new BUY ideas. In the next few weeks an oversold condition should give us the next bargain BUY window. Keep an eye out for this Action Alert in your email inbox. 

If you would like to receive future SER Action BUY Recommendations, become a subscriber. https://schachterenergyreport.ca/subscriptions/

Our first issue of 2025 is our Fearless Forecast issue (out January 16, 2025) and includes our outlook for each of the two key commodities and a recap of our favourite BUY ideas. This is always one of our most read issues.

Share the Eye on Energy

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Scroll to Top