Schachter Energy Report

Eye on Energy: January 15
Schachter's Eye on Energy

Bidens New Sanctions On Russia Lift Crude Prices >10% In One Week. Expect Reversal Once Trump Takes Office.

The quick rise in crude oil prices over the last week after the Biden/Russia black fleet shipping sanctions were announced, lifted crude by 10%. We see this reversing starting next week once Trump is inaugurated with crude retreating to a downside target range of US$66-68/b. This should trigger a new long-term buy signal for the sector. Russia has always found ways around the sanctions and we see this as just another logistics challenge. Also remember that President Trump could reverse the sanctions to get President Putin to the negotiating table with Ukraine. Normally just one of the three BUY signals we watch is sufficient for us to send out BUY recommendations. This is what happened in September (September 10th) when WTI fell to US$66/b and we sent out an Action BUY signal and added five new energy ideas to our BUY list. We are watching our three indicators (WTI price, S&P/TSX Energy Index level and the S&P Energy Bullish Percent Index) and we may see more than one of these signals triggered in the coming weeks. When this happens we will send an email to SER subscribers with new BUY ideas and note those stocks that are at bargain levels for subscribers to consider. This next BUY window may see more than one signal being triggered at the same time which historically has been a high reward situation. The last time this occurred was in March 2020, a very rewarding BUY window for investors. Keep an eye out for an SER Action Alert in the coming weeks. We see late January/February 2025 as likely a weak general stock market period. 

Global Economic, Political & Military Update

The Biden administration leaves next week but continues its scorched earth plan to make Trump’s taking over power difficult. The White House continues to spend whatever funds authorized by Congress and that the President can spend under Presidential authority before Inauguration Day. The result may be that the incoming administration comes in with a run rate of a US$3T+ deficit and all Biden’s favourite programs (climate, more government hiring etc.) getting more funds to spend. Every department has been told to spend all authorizations and leave no funds unspent. This makes it harder for the new administration to reign in the policies that they were elected on, such as cutting government pork spending.  If the goal of the Biden administration was to leave the new administration with geopolitical, financial and economic challenges that mess up implementing their agenda, they have succeeded. It is unlikely that the people’s business will be done in the next few months as the political drama unfolds. This Presidential transition seems to be one of the worst ever as Biden’s White House staffers do everything they can to make the start of Trump’s Presidency difficult. 

President Trump wants to focus initially on the border crisis and boosting US energy production, while his DOGE team gets a handle on government waste. This is what the markets will be watching for in the first days of his new Presidency. Will he get all he wants done in one, two or three bills and can Congress pass more than one bill in 2025. History says this is unlikely. He continued his comments about taking over Greenland and the Panama canal for the security of the US. In addition, he is threatening NATO members that if they don’t raise their defense spending to 5% of GDP from the current target of 2% then he will withdraw the US military umbrella. Canada was specifically called out and he repeated his view of Canada becoming the 51st state and our Prime Minister becoming a Governor. Thankfully he is aware of Trudeau’s resignation and if the Conservatives win the upcoming election there will be a better meeting of the minds between the two leaders going forward. Canada and the US have a long standing relationship that needs to be nurtured and not neutered. Next week’s US tariff moves and levels will tell the tale of how this relationship will move forward. President Trump is now calling for an “External Revenue Service” to collect the massive Tariffs and Duties from foreign sources. This may  require an act of Congress to create a  new federal agency.

The President’s key cabinet and other lieutenants continue to go through the Senate confirmation process. The Defense pick Hegseth was supported by Republicans but was unanimously condemned by Democrats. The first 100 days that Trump wanted to see major directional and policy changes may not be possible given the problems in Congress with divergent groups and the slow way that the Senate moves. 

Some of the recent tug of war economic data includes:

  • US Core CPI rose 3.2% in December but this data does not include the 10% rise in crude oil prices that will lift this result next month. Core CPI rose 0.4% month over month so inflation has bottomed and we see it rising in the coming months.
  • Core PPI rose 0.3% in December but in the details it was not so positive. The PPI for final demand rose 0.4% in December and prices for goods rose by 0.7%.
  • NY Empire State Manufacturing took a dip to a minus 12.6 from a prior +2.1. 
  • US December payrolls rose a whopping 256K jobs way above the forecast of 164K new jobs. Private Employment gained 223K jobs. Average hourly earnings rose 3.9% year over year only slightly below the 4.0% of November. 
  • President Biden has hundreds of thousands of people from El Salvador and Venezuela staying in the country as he extended their deportations by 18 months or more under his amnesty program that Trump would never have done.
  • Biden has rushed to regulate AI before Trump takes office. 
  • Biden has added another 150K borrowers student loan debt relief of US$183B.

In our upcoming first SER issue of 2025 to come out on January 16th we plan to cover many of the topics which may impact the investment markets in 2025. If these are of interest to you, become a subscriber.

Geopolitical Military Issues:

Ukraine/Russia – Russia Moves Aggressively before January 20th

President Biden has put on stricter sanctions against the >140 Russian ships carrying crude to its customers. These customers are mainly China (2.16 Mb/d) and India (1.76 mb/d). Historically, Russia and its customers have found work arounds for the sanctions and we see the same occurring in the coming months. This is a short term phenomenon. Crude rose from US$70/b to over US$79/b in just a few days. Crude is now overbought and we would recommend holding off on adding to positions at this time. Once we breach US$70/b begin looking for bargains once again. Crude should retreat as many countries are in recession (Germany and the UK for example) and the new trade tariffs to be announced next week by the Trump administration should impact world trade and prices. 

Russia is fighting off new attacks by Ukraine’s forces in its Kursk region. Zelensky has moved in more of his best troops to regain Russian territory before inauguration day so he can have leverage when diplomatic talks commences. The recent death toll on both sides is horrendous (more than 10,000 each) but it looks like the movement of new troops to this area by Ukraine has left parts of eastern Ukraine open to Russian advances. Russia recently announced the capture of an important logistics hub at Kurakhove. It is now advancing to capture a rail and road hub at Pokrovsk according to the Washington Post.  

Putin wants to expel the Ukrainian forces before January 20th. It would give him more bargaining power when President Trump pushes for a diplomatic solution. He may not succeed in this as that date is approaching quickly. Russia is aided in the front lines by North Korea which is sending Russia more military manpower, more ammunition, rocket launchers, suicide drones and self-propelled artillery as their relationship expands. In return North Korea is gaining much needed modern warfare experience, food aid, crude oil, advanced space technologies and lots of money from Russia. President Kim is running North Korea’s military industrial complex flat out to supply Russia with needed munitions and equipment. If there is a diplomatic resolution then this gravy train would end for North Korea so they are going all out while they have the opportunity. Time now is not on the side of either Russia or Ukraine. 

Israel/Hamas Negotiations

Israel and Hamas have announced an initial deal to gradually free 33 of the 98 hostages (some dead) and include women and children and those over 50. This phase would last six weeks and see hundreds of Palestinians freed. Israel would begin to withdraw from Gaza’s population centres and displaced Palestinians could return home. Over 600 trucks of humanitarian aid would enter Gaza each day. Subsequent phases would be worked out as this initial phase is implemented. Israel believes that there are 98 hostages in total and that 30 or more are now dead. Talks continue in Doha, Qatar to finalize a draft of the deal. Both sides are there but have not been seen in the same room together yet. In return for the Israeli hostages hundreds of Gazans/Palestinians prisoners will be released some of whom were convicted of terrorism. How this plays out over the coming weeks will be watched to see if future deal extensions occur. 

A problem for Israel is that Hamas has rebuilt its organization with a new leader at the helm. The brother (Mohammed Sinwar) of the former Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar has become the new leader of Hamas and he has recruited thousands of new fighters. My concern is who controls Gaza after all the hostages have been released. Will it be Hamas or intermediaries keeping the peace? 

Regarding energy, 

Our WTI price target of US$66-69/b was reached in September and is likely to do so again in the coming weeks. Today WTI is at US$79.45/b as bullish investors take very large long positions. We expect a period of backing and filling for WTI crude in the coming weeks and another test of the lows (US$66-68/b). When this occurs we should see another BUY signal triggered. We plan to add additional BUY ideas at that time. Subscribers please watch your emails on weak market days as this is when such an Action Alert would be issued. 

If you want to see what our subscribers are looking at, sign up now for access to the Schachter Energy Research reports.

EIA Weekly Oil Data:

The EIA data for last week was a modestly bearish report. US Commercial Crude Inventories shrunk 2.0 Mb offset by the SPR growing by a modest 500 Kb. The bearish part was that Domestic Production fell 82 Kb/d to 13.48 Mb/d and is only up 181 Kb/d from last year. US Exports rose 1.0 Mb/d to 4.08 Mb/d. Motor Gasoline Stocks rose 5.9 Mb while Distillate supplies rose 3.1 Mb. 

Total Product Supplied increased 882 Kb/d to 20.7 Mb/d as Distillate demand rose 661 Kb/d.  Motor Gasoline demand fell by 156 Kb/d last week to 8.3 Mb/d, while Jet Fuel demand fell 234 Kb/d to 1.49 Mb/d. Refinery Utilization came in at 91.7% down 1.6% from last week and below the 2024 level of 92.6%. Cushing Storage rose 800 Kb/d to 20.8 Mb and was significantly below 32.1 Mb held in 2024. 

Total US Demand is year-to-date at 20.5 Mb/d up 3.6% from 19.8 Mb/d in 2024. Motor Gasoline Demand is at 8.36 Mb/d up 0.8% from 8.29 Mb/d in 2023. These growth numbers are getting better each week. This positive comparison is why we see 2025 US consumption rising. 

OPEC Monthly report:

The January 2025 report released January 15th (today) showed that in December, OPEC saw a production increase of 26 Kb/d due to Libya’s production continuing to return and lifted crude volumes 53 Kb/d to 1.29 Mb/d to 1.24 Mb/d. The fight over revenues between the eastern and western thugs seems to have been resolved for now. Nigeria added 30 Kb/d to 3.51 Mb/d. Cuts occurred from Iraq (down 22 Kb/d to 4.02 Mb/d – due to excess quota production) and from Saudi Arabia (down 23 Kb/d to 8.94 Mb/d). 

Canada now is number four in the world production rankings. First is the US at 22.5 Mb/d, then Russia at 8.99 Mb/d, then Saudi Arabia at 8.96 Mb/d and then Canada at 6.1 Mb/d (Canada exported to the US 4.42 Mb/d in the first week of January 2025). Below us is China at 4.6 Mb/d. We could be producing so much more if there was support at all levels of government and we could add more western takeaway capacity. That could be a possibility once the new Trump administration returns to power in January and we see a pro-energy government in Ottawa. 

China demand continues to be weak (Fuel oil demand is down 26.5% and Gasoline demand fell 2.0%). Overall demand grew 0.6% to 16.6 Mb/d as Jet Fuel demand grew 7.3%. India saw growth of 7.9% to 5.74 Mb/d from 5.32 Mb/d in November 2023. Jet Fuel and Gasoline showed the best growth rates.  

OPEC now sees 2025 demand growth at 1.45 Mb/d after forecasting at the beginning of the year a demand spurt of 2.2 Mb/d. We remain at 1.5 Mb/d for 2025. Our thesis is that global growth will get back on track during 2H/25 and prices will lift over US$90/b during Q4/25. More on this in our January 2025 SER Fearless Forecast issue.

EIA Weekly Natural Gas Data

A warmer spell over the last week helped to draw storage down but at a more moderate pace than prior weeks. Storage fell 40 Bcf to 3.37 Tcf with the largest decline in the Midwest with a 33 Bcf usage. This compares to a decrease of 140 Bcf last year and the 5-year average withdrawal rate of 97 Bcf. With a Polar Vortex bringing cold weather and snow down to Texas in the next week or so, the withdrawal rates should pick up sharply. We expect to see many weeks of withdrawals over 200 Bcf per week this winter season. Normally those big draw weeks hit in the end of January and through February. 

US Storage is now 0.1% below last year’s level of 3.38 Tcf but still above the five year average of 3.17 Tcf (6.5%). Once we see the current week shrink below the five year average we see prices for NYMEX lifting nicely over US$4.00/mcf. NYMEX is today priced at US$4.03/mcf. Spikes over US$5/mcf should be seen this winter during very cold days when electricity systems are maxed out. 

We recommend buying the very depressed natural gas stocks during periods of market weakness. Natural gas stocks are very cheap now. We see much much higher gas prices in 2H/25 as quite a number of new LNG plants come onstream over the next 12 months; one in Canada and two more in the US. In Canada the first train of LNG Canada comes on during Q2/25 and in the US Corpus Christi Stage 3 begins production of LNG (1.5 Bcf/d). In 2025, Golden Pass LNG is bringing on the first two trains of this new three train export facility. The US saw a ramp-up in feedgas deliveries to an all time high of more than 15.3 Bcf/d as the new Plaquemines LNG plant started up and shipped its first cargo to Germany. 

THREE DAYS LEFT! GET THIS GREAT OFFER BEFORE IT IS GONE ON FRIDAY NIGHT! – FOR NEW SUBSCRIBERS! 

holiday special

We are keeping open our holiday special deal for new subscribers. Get $100 off for your first annual term with code HOLA24 or $50 off your first quarter term with code HOLQ24. Now is a great time to subscribe as there are many bargains to invest in. To subscribe click on the link below and make sure to type in the coupon code. https://schachterenergyreport.ca/subscriptions/

Baker Hughes Rig Data

In the data for the week ending January 10th, the US rig count fell five rigs to 584 rigs. Rig activity is now 5.7% below the level of 619 rigs working last year. Of the total US rigs working last week, 480 were drilling for oil and this is 3.8% below last year’s level of 499 rigs working. The natural gas rig count is down 14.5% from last year’s 117 rigs, now at 100 rigs. This decline in drilling and production should continue for a few more months as the industry waits to see Trump’s industry support and the industry waits to see natural gas inventories fall below the five-year average. Once this occurs we should see NYMEX prices recover. Weak WTI prices at this time should slow energy companies drilling plans for early 2025.

In Canada, there was a large 122 rig increase to 216 rigs as the industry ramped up to drill out 2025 drilling budgets. This rig activity rate was above last year’s 213 rigs, or up by 1.4%. The industry needs north of $2.50/mcf to see the economics attractive to drill dry gas wells. As we get closer to LNG Canada ramping up in 1H/25 and natural gas fills the Coastal GasLink pipeline, prices should lift. AECO prices are at uneconomic prices around $1.90/mcf. Starting week two of January we should see these numbers rise quickly as the industry returns to work with funds from 2025 budgets. 

Energy Stock Market

The S&P/TSX Energy Index today is at 280, up one point since our report last week. We think last week’s crude oil price bounce is near exhaustion. Our downside target for this Index remains below 240 (range 230-240) and we see this happening over the coming weeks. We like to BUY when stocks are cheap and being ignored. Bargains are clearly being seen now in our focus for new recommendations. WTI has traded between US$65.27/b and US$78.46/b over the past few months. The higher end when there are war actions in the Middle East with Iran involved and the lower end when weak crude demand data is released.

Investors should decide what you want your energy weighting to be for this long energy super cycle. Our BUY List includes ideas from the Pipeline/Infrastructure/Royalty area, Canadian oil and natural gas ideas, energy service ideas and companies working internationally. Our list includes large Conservative ideas and small to large caps in our Growth and Entrepreneurial categories. Add to your current ideas or add new ideas. We expect that WTI should lift above US$90/b in 2H/25 and demand should exceed supplies at that time. We see WTI prices above US$100/b consistently during 2026. 

We expect we are close to another low risk entry point like we saw on September 10th when we sent out an Action Alert BUY with five new BUY ideas. In the next few weeks an oversold condition should give us the next bargain BUY window. Keep an eye out for this Action Alert in your email inbox. 

If you would like to receive future SER Action BUY Recommendations, become a subscriber. https://schachterenergyreport.ca/subscriptions/

Our first issue of 2025 is our Fearless Forecast issue (out tomorrow, January 16, 2025) which includes our outlook for each of the two key energy commodities and a recap of our favourite BUY ideas to purchase when the correction runs its course. This is always one of our most read issues. We cover the key themes that likely will hold the market's attention in 2025 and our view on each. These include rising inflation pressures, crowding out in the bond market and rising interest rates, President Trump’s tariff plans, his agenda on energy, arresting and deporting criminal illegal immigrants, and tax cut extension, DOGE and his goal to cut regulations. Especially to reverse the late moves by President Biden to hamstring Trump’s agenda that differ so much from Biden’s progressive left wing views. We show our forecast range for WTI crude prices by quarter with the highest prices expected in Q4/25. Our Q1/25 has a range forecast of US$66/b to US$78/b. We are now at the higher end of this range so caution is advised in adding to positions at this time.

We are now seeing the early part of 2025 as volatile. In the coming weeks we see material downside but we are more optimistic about 2H/25. We see energy having a very rewarding period for investors from the Q1/25 low into year end. Some of the BUY ideas we show could see upside of 50% or more into year end. Some energy stocks have bounced 20% from the tax loss selling lows. We may see a test of those lows in the coming weeks. Keep an eye out for an SER Action Alert if any of our BUY signals are triggered and we add new names to our BUY list as well as reiterate BUYS on ideas on our current List that have retreated to bargain levels.

Share the Eye on Energy

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Scroll to Top